A Good Trade Vs A Bad Trade

Bravetotrade Mod Updated   
NSE:NIFTY   Nifty 50 Index
The Good Trade Process

A good trader would do some analysis post market, some do it in the evening while the others at night but the time of analysis does not matter. He searches for his favorite setups on higher time frame charts and look for potential opportunities. He takes down only those trades which qualify his risk appetite. Opportunities with 1:2 or more risk to reward ratio are normally good for consistent traders.
The trader sits patiently and wait for setups/strategy to complete and looks into lower timeframe charts to finetune his entry if possible.
Discipline is followed for exits and stops, which are not moved (few exceptions) after the trade is initiated.

If the trader follows the above tenets but a trade turns out to be a loser, I would definitely call it a Good Trade because he followed the right process. One needs to accept that in trading business one has no control over the results but the process.

Post analysis helps the trader to know his weaknesses. He notes down his weaknesses after each trade and plans what he can do about it.

A Bad Trade

A Bad trade is exactly the opposite of a good trade. None of the above traits are followed. The trader takes position chasing a breakout or trades a pullback coz prices are lower. No proper setups are followed and risk reward ratio is poor. Stops are moved when they are about to hit and profits are taken before targets are reached. With this type of trading, the trader can not survive the market for long. Soon he bursts his account. The trader is so desperate after watching his PnL that he can't even post analyse his trades in frustration. This only
reflects that he is not learning, he just wants money. But the truth is that learning is an ever ending process in any field.

If the trading process is not followed but a trade comes out to be a profitable one, I will definitely call it a Bad Trade.

Trading Performance:

One should never judge his trading potential just on the basis of few losing trades. Losses are part of trading business (but only if one is taking it as a business and not Casino). Few losing trades are just part of those hundreds trades that one will take in future. So with the right trading process, the chances are rare that a trader ends up as a loser after those few hundred trades. For that one surely needs to assess his trading strategy and psychology at least every three months, for early improvements.

Hope above information from my experience will help some traders to overcome failures and the other to improve their trading.

Comment: Hi there,

I would like to extend this discussion a bit. Its about the "Fear of Loss".
Almost every trader faces this situation once or more in his trading career. But there is need to come out of this phase and carry on but How?

A new trader do not have this kinda fear but he has another fear, the " Fear of Missing a Trade". So he takes positions in haste and sometimes make money but loses in multiples, later in a similar trade. After losing again and again he comes to a threshold where he suffers from the fear of loss.

The traders who have lost big money even in good setups, may be because of lousy psychological mistakes or the overall market sentiment, hesitate on pulling the trigger. THIS PROBLEM IS THERE EVEN WITH MANY EXPERIENCED TRADERS TOO. We suffer a big loss on one trade and then we kinda cool down for the whole month before we trade next month. There is nothing wrong in this unless we utilize the cool off period to learn from our mistakes rather than fuming and regretting. BUT if it is happening very often that we end up losing trades again and again and again, then there is definitely something wrong either with our strategy or psychology.

How to overcome this problem?

I would suggest to reduce position sizes. I know that's not possible in futures market when we trade with single lot. In that case paper trade could be a good option. It does not makes you any money but you won't lose money AND the best part is that you are learning now. Just follow the tenets of a good trade discussed in this post.

After some hiccups and improvements in you strategy, you will come at a point where you will be confident about your strategy. Now you will put it into practice.

For precautionary measures and to build confidence I would suggest to take as small positions as possible, that too only when risk is in 'your' limits. After being a consistent winner with this much position size, increase it to next level and keep on gradually increasing till you reach a threshold where you will feel uncomfortable taking that heavy position. Stop there and trade with your previous position size till you are more confident.

Trust me guys this simple trick has a huge psychological impact on our trading style. Try this and be a profitable trader.

JJ Singh
Full TIme Trader/Investor
Moderator, TradingView

✅Free Telegram channel for live analysis at

✅Tweet at

The information and publications are not meant to be, and do not constitute, financial, investment, trading, or other types of advice or recommendations supplied or endorsed by TradingView. Read more in the Terms of Use.