Manual Trading vs. Algo Trading: What’s the Future?Hello Traders!
In today’s post, we’ll explore a hot topic in the trading world – Manual Trading vs. Algo Trading , and discuss the pros and cons of each. These two approaches to trading have been gaining popularity, but the question remains: which one is better, and what does the future hold for both?
What is Manual Trading ?
Manual trading is the traditional form of trading where the trader makes all the decisions. This includes identifying entry and exit points , using technical indicators , and analyzing the market to make informed decisions. Traders who use manual trading rely heavily on their experience , emotion , and intuition to decide when to buy or sell.
What is Algo Trading ?
On the other hand, Algo trading uses computer algorithms and pre-programmed instructions to execute trades. It’s based on a set of rules, such as price , volume , and time , to determine when a trade should be placed. This method eliminates human emotion, and trades are executed with precision and speed, often in milliseconds . Algo traders use advanced tools like artificial intelligence (AI) , machine learning , and big data to build smarter trading strategies.
Pros of Manual Trading
Human Element : Manual traders can rely on their intuition, experience, and emotions to make informed decisions. This helps them adjust to market nuances and situations that algorithms may miss.
Flexibility : Manual traders have the ability to make on-the-spot decisions based on changing market conditions.
Emotional Control : Although emotions can be a downside, a skilled manual trader knows how to manage emotions effectively, which allows them to make calculated decisions.
Pros of Algo Trading
Speed and Efficiency : Algo trading can process large amounts of data quickly, making trades in milliseconds. This can be advantageous in fast-moving markets.
Reduced Emotional Bias : Since the algorithm follows strict rules, there’s no emotional interference, making the process more rational and systematic.
Backtesting : With algo trading , traders can backtest strategies against historical data to see how the algorithm would have performed, helping to fine-tune strategies.
24/7 Trading : Algo trading can run continuously, taking advantage of global markets and never missing trading opportunities.
Cons of Manual Trading
Time-Consuming : Manual trading requires a lot of attention and focus, which can be mentally exhausting, especially during volatile markets.
Emotional Impact : Emotions such as fear and greed can affect a trader’s decision-making process, leading to mistakes.
Limited to Available Time : Traders are limited by time and must be physically present to execute trades.
Cons of Algo Trading
Technical Issues : Algorithms can fail or face technical glitches, leading to unexpected losses.
Lack of Adaptability : Algorithms are designed to follow rules, which means they may not adapt well to unexpected market events or major news.
Over-Optimization Risk : Over-optimized strategies may perform well in backtests but can fail in real market conditions.
The Future of Trading
As technology continues to advance, the future of trading will likely see more integration of AI , big data , and machine learning in both manual and algo trading . While algo trading will continue to dominate for its speed, efficiency, and ability to trade large volumes, manual trading still holds value for traders who rely on their judgment, intuition, and ability to adapt to rapidly changing market conditions.
Conclusion: Manual trading and algo trading each have their unique advantages. If you’re someone who enjoys making quick decisions and analyzing the market based on real-time information, manual trading might be your best fit. However, if you prefer speed , automation , and trading without emotional bias, algo trading could be the way to go.
What are your thoughts on Manual Trading vs. Algo Trading ? Share your experience and insights in the comments below! Let’s learn from each other!
Algorithmictrading
22 Mar ’24 — BankNifty holds ground, when NiftyIT was crashingBankNifty Analysis - Stance Neutral ➡️
BankNifty stays in the neutral zone for yet another day. Even when N50 made its 1.36%, BN went up only by 0.9%. NiftyIT was tanking on one side, but BN was holding its ground from falling. I am seriously confused about whether Nifty or BankNifty has the lower beta. Even the profit booking in the last 40mts did not have a wild impact on BN but it might have taken the profits out of N50 straddlers.
4mts chart
We are almost midway between the nearest support & resistance. The slope of the 200 EMA will prove the point that we are neutral, just check its slope - it's almost parallel to the X-axis. This was the major reason why I never went bearish even though we fell 2000+ points from the ATH. We continue to maintain our neutral stance for Tuesday and would like to build fresh positions based on the price action.
63mts chart
—
Algo Trading
Our algo trades ended today with a loss of 7029 rupees, thanks to the swing from Nifty50. So for my current month, the Nifty Algos are in loss whereas BN is in good profits. This takes me back to the earlier question, which one has the lower beta?
19 Mar ’24 — BankNifty has another 300pts to go Bearish 🐻🐻🐻BankNifty Analysis - Stance Neutral ➡️
The level of reluctance BankNifty shows to crack is really intense. Usually, Banks react badly to any situation. We now have a peculiar case wherein Nifty has been downward facing for the last 3 consecutive sessions whereas BankNifty has stayed neutral. BankNifty has been losing points steadily, eg: it lost 191pts today but the bearish intent is not there. And you know pretty well we cannot change the status to bearish unless the “Bears” actually push down the index with momentum. We would need a breach of support or a re-entry to the bearish channel for that.
4mts chart
Even though BN lost a few points today, it was nothing comparable to Nifty (-1.08%) and NiftyIT (-2.9%). None of the Nifty subsectors were in Green today. The main sector fighting for the bulls was the Financials. My eyes were totally glued on ICICI Bank and HDFC Bank today, despite N50 falling both these banks held their ground pretty strongly. In many instances, both were trading against the current.
On the higher time frame, BN has less than 300pts to enter the bearish channel. Tomorrow being the weekly expiry, we are pinning the hopes for a classic bear attack. We would prefer to start the day neutral and go short only if the conditions are met. A rising VIX would be the 2nd clue we might be watching for.
63mts chart
–
Algo Trading
Our algo trades ended today with a gain of Rs27216. I wound up the trades at 12.48 as almost 95% of the target was done and did not want to lose out to a possible directional trend.
14 Mar ’24 — BankNifty's price action overshadowed by NiftyITBankNifty Analysis - Stance Neutral ➡️
Banks were performing as expected today, even though we had a neutral view we ended up losing 0.41% for the day. The stance for tomorrow also continues to be neutral as BN did not breach support or resistance today. The starting candle was perfect as per the script, from there we rose 666pts ~ 1.43% to reach the HOD of 47231 by 11.43. The staling was obvious as there were no special triggers to take up even near the resistance level of 47465.
4mts chart
The fall of 536pts ~ 1.14% from the day’s high also made perfect sense. Unfortunately, Nifty50 does not convey the real truth that happened with the banks as that index was overshadowed by stocks like Adani and NiftyIT components.
On the 63mts time frame, the lower high formation looks much better than N50. Our stance continues to be neutral and would go short if we enter the bearish channel and would go long if the 47465 resistance is breached.
63mts chart
–
Algo Trading
Our algo trades ended today with a gain of Rs21565. Even though we had a quick dip in profits by 10.37, the system recovered and closed in green.